
Mental health diagnosis should be more collaborative
By Gerry O Sullivan
Posted: 26 April, 2018
Student support is a key part of the provision for students from all backgrounds. The University of East Anglia in the UK has been looking at the area of mental health diagnosis
Source: www.alphagalileo.org
Mental health diagnosis should be a collaborative and useful process, not a meaningless label – according to new research from Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust (NSFT) and the University of East Anglia.
Doctors should work alongside service users to approach diagnosis in a way that is sensitive to individual needs and preferences, so that they explain difficulties, give hope, empower and guide recovery.
A study, published today in The Lancet Psychiatry, offers practical guidance for doctors and could lead to service users having a better experience of diagnosis.
The research was undertaken by a team that included a clinician and a service-user from the Department of Research and Development at Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust (NSFT) and researchers at the Norwich Medical School at the University of East Anglia (UEA).
The major review synthesises for the first time the perspectives of service-users, carers and doctors in an attempt to understand and improve the diagnostic journey. It contains data from 13 countries and includes more than 2,220 participants.
One of the authors, Dr Corinna Hackmann, a research clinical psychologist based at Hellesdon Hospital, Norwich, said that diagnosis can be validating and helpful but can also be detrimental and lead to stigma.
“For me, an interesting finding of this study is the discrepancy between the views of service users and clinicians,” she said.
“Many doctors feel that service users have a right to know their diagnosis but at the same time rightly fear the potential harm this might cause, which can be associated with withholding or delaying sharing the diagnosis.
“However, the results suggested that if a diagnosis is made, service-users would prefer that it is shared and discussed with them rather than withheld.”
Dr Caitlin Notley, from UEA’s Norwich Medical School, said: “This research supports a sensitive, individualised, collaborative, and holistic approach to mental health diagnosis, which is informative, can empower service users, provide hope and guide treatment.”
A major diagnostic manual, the International Classification of Disease – 11th revision (ICD-11) is set for release by the World Health Organisation (WHO) this summer. This study forms part of an important and timely programme of International research aimed at improving the diagnostic process in collaboration with service-users.
“We have developed research in dialogue with the WHO that feeds service-user views into the process of revision for the ICD-11,” said Dr Hackmann.
The paper reports that diagnosis can be experienced as labelling and this can cause stigma.
The authors found evidence of feelings of isolation, confusion, insignificance or distress when a diagnosis is not discussed with service-users, is discovered via health records, in a letter or inadvertently mentioned in a care meeting.
The study suggests that service-users prefer their diagnosis to be given face-to-face, with helpful information, and clearly leading to reciprocal discussions about care-needs and treatment.
Dr Hackmann co-authored the study with Amorette Perkins and Joseph Ridler (former Research Assistant Psychologists) and Daniel Browes (expert by experience and former Peer Support Worker) and colleagues from Norwich Medical School and the School of Health Sciences at UEA – Dr Caitlin Notley, Senior Lecturer in Mental Health; and Dr Guy Peryer, Lecturer in Health Sciences.
-
-
16 December, 2020
Over 5000 events celebrate the Erasmus Programme in 2020
-
12 December, 2020
Next Erasmus+ Programme clears political hurdle
-
6 December, 2020
Erasmus Barometer Survey 2019-2020 Open
-
6 October, 2020
Four Irish HEIs in share of €5m EU Knowledge Alliance Funding
-
-
28 September, 2020
€239,696 in Jean Monnet funding awarded to two Universities
-
27 August, 2020
EU launches COVID Response Project Call
-
20 August, 2020
EC to launch Digital Education Strategic Partnerships Call
-
23 July, 2020
6 Irish HEIs to share in €36m Erasmus Mundus Programme
-
-
-
-
2 July, 2020
Europass: take the next step! New platform launched
-
22 June, 2020
Ulysses Call 2020 – Results
-
-
17 March, 2020
New Deadlines for Erasmus+ Sport Actions
-
12 March, 2020
Coronavirus – Statement from An Taoiseach
-
-
-
27 February, 2020
Erasmus+ Project opens door to Algerian partnership for UL
-
24 February, 2020
Intra-Africa Academic Mobility Scheme fourth Call
-
14 February, 2020
European Policy Experimentations – Call 2020
-
13 February, 2020
Secular cultures more welcoming according to new study
-
-
3 February, 2020
Coronavirus Research Call
-
-
8 January, 2020
Brazilian Universities develop new performance metrics
-
-
20 December, 2019
Photo Competition to celebrate 10 million Erasmus Students
-
16 December, 2019
Erasmus Days 2019 a huge success
-
12 December, 2019
Cork IT Erasmus Student wins prestigious music award
-
11 December, 2019
International Scholarship Call to issue in January 2020
-
8 November, 2019
Erasmus+ 2020 Call and Programme Guide 2020
-
4 November, 2019
Three HEIs in latest Erasmus Mundus awards
-
-
9 September, 2019
The future of European research must be inclusive
-
30 August, 2019
Government Investment to benefit internationalisation
-
28 August, 2019
Almost 100 Mobilities to Palestine in 2018 from Europe
-
26 August, 2019
Latest Edition of the Armenian E+ Office Newsletter
-
12 August, 2019
Irish Universities win nearly €2m of EU support
-
-
-
5 June, 2019
DCU – World Leader in addressing bullying
-
29 May, 2019
Brexit – Continuation of Erasmus+
-
-
-
-
-
11 March, 2019
Old Dominion University on a visit to Ireland
-
10 March, 2019
Carnaval at MIC
-
-
-
27 February, 2019
500 participants attend Palestinian National Erasmus+ Office INFO Day
-
26 February, 2019
Seed funding call for Teacher Education North and South launched
-
22 February, 2019
Universities UK calls on UK government to fund study abroad
-
-
19 February, 2019
U-Multirank Call 2019 – Deadline 1 May 2019
-
7 February, 2019
Erasmus+ and a “No Deal” Brexit – EC Statement
-
1 February, 2019
Erasmus+ Application Deadline extended to 12 February
-
-
20 December, 2018
Unusual Stats for Christmas
-
16 November, 2018
Erasmus+ Languages Survey
-
-
-
24 October, 2018
European Commission publishes Erasmus+ Call 2019
-
8 October, 2018
Mobility under Erasmus+: European Court of Auditors Report
-
17 September, 2018
RCSI to deliver joint pharmacy programme with Chinese University
-
10 September, 2018
World Suicide Prevention Day 10 September 2018
-
-
-
-
28 August, 2018
Finland aims to be at the forefront of the Arctic bioeconomy
-
-
-
14 August, 2018
EU agrees a number of joint initiatives with Japan
-
-
-
-
22 June, 2018
Ireland an EU leader in Innovation
-
21 June, 2018
EU’s External Budget – €123 billion proposed for 2021-27
-
-
-
-
15 June, 2018
Palestine Erasmus+ Office launches newsletter
-
-
3 June, 2018
Irish SMEs among winners in Commission Programme
-
-
11 May, 2018
RTÉ Brainstorm
-
3 May, 2018
Career Guidance – Public Consultation
-
-
-
27 April, 2018
Global Survey on Internationalisation
-