
New HEA Report Shows non-Irish students perform better than Irish students
By Aoileann Ní Bhroin
Posted: 25 May, 2018
A new report by the Higher Education Authority (HEA) reveals that non-Irish students have a slightly higher progression rate (from Year 1 to Year 2) than Irish (domestic) students. The report found that 14% of non-Irish students across all study levels in 2014-15 do not progress to Year 2 of their programme compared to 15% of Irish students.
Overall the report found that 86% of the 2014/15 first year undergraduate new entrants in publicly funded higher education institutions (seven universities, fourteen institutes of technology and six colleges) progress to second year.
A total of 41,441 new entrants to the higher education system were tracked and the 86% progression rate is a slight improvement on the 85% rate from 2013/14.
Those with higher prior educational attainment, i.e higher Leaving Certificate points are more likely to progress to the second year of study than those with lower educational attainment and females are more likely than males to progress across all levels and sectors (89% to 83%).
The study also examined the relationship between the type of school attended and progression rates in college. The rates of non-progression are almost double for students from DEIS schools compared to students from fee paying schools (19% v 10%). Rates for students from standard schools are equal to the overall mean non-progression rate of 14%.
It should be noted that those who don’t progress may not have ‘dropped out’ – some will repeat the year, some may have left for personal reasons to return later, some will have decided to change course. For that reason, we refer to not going on to second year as ‘non-progression’.
The typical student most likely to progress into second year will be a female studying education or healthcare in a university or college, with relatively high Leaving Cert points. The student most likely not to progress will be a male, with relatively low Leaving Cert points, studying a Level 6 or Level 7 course at an Institute of Technology in computer science, construction or engineering.
Key Findings
Among the key findings in the report –
- Rates of non-progression vary across fields of study. Construction and Related disciplines have the highest non-progression rate at 23%. However, this is down five percentage points from the year previous. Like previous years, Medicine has the lowest non-progression rate of all 2014/15 new entrants in profession-oriented courses, at two percent, while Architecture has the highest rate at 20%.
- The rates of non-progression in 2014/15 varied within and between sectors ranging from 27% and 25% at levels 6 and 7 in the Institutes of Technology compared to 15%, 10% and 8% at level 8 in institutes of technology, universities and colleges respectively.
- In the institute of technology sector at level 6, level 7 and level 8, mature students are more likely to progress to the following year of study than a new entrant who is under the age of 23. The opposite is true at level 8 in the university and colleges sector, where younger students are more likely to progress than mature students.
- Across all levels and sectors, Irish students had a non-progression rate of 15% compared to 14% among non-Irish students.
- Prior academic attainment (Leaving Certificate points) is the strongest predictor of nonprogression. Those entering with lower points are much more likely to not progress compared to those entering with higher points, even after controlling for the set of student and course/ institute characteristics.
- Although headline rates of non-progression are generally much higher in institutes of technology than in universities, after controlling for the set of student and course/institute characteristics, particularly prior academic attainment of the student intake (Leaving Certificate points), the odds ratios are quite close across most institutes with the odds of not progressing actually higher in some universities than in some of the institutes of technology.
Guidance Needed and Equity Gap Must Be Tackled
Dr. Graham Love, Chief Executive of the HEA, commented,
“There are positive trends in the higher education system as we see small increases in the proportion of students who do progress from first to second year. Generally, if a student can get to second year, he or she is highly likely to complete their course.”
“However, the continuing relatively high non-progression rates on some Level 6 and 7 courses in computing, engineering and construction remains a worry. The majority of these students are male. They may learn in a different way and I am glad that the new apprenticeships model is responding to that way of learning. We also need to ensure that there is adequate guidance and information at second level. There is a personal and financial cost to the individual student if he or she does not complete their College course; there is also a cost to the State. We need to ask if students are picking wrong courses and how can we help ensure that they make the right choice.”
In addition, he remarked on the continuing equity gap,
“We have an education system that is committed to access and to equality but it is still clear that a student from a financially better off background and who may have been able to attend a fee-paying school has an advantage over those from less well-off backgrounds.”
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
6 December, 2021
Access and inclusion for persons with disability
-
-
-
8 November, 2021
Three institutions successful in ECHE 2021 Call
-
1 November, 2021
Increased Financial Support for Inclusion in Erasmus+ Programme
-
26 October, 2021
€9.2m allocated for Year 1 of new Erasmus+ Programme
-
-
-
28 September, 2021
TU Dublin Student Kevin McGrath explores “space” on his Erasmus+ Traineeship
-
27 September, 2021
Commission President commits EU to tackling global challenges
-
21 September, 2021
The future “is digital” as European Commission launches Erasmus+ App
-
15 September, 2021
UCD’s Dipti Pandya – Erasmus, Maynooth and the “Glenroe” Theme Tune
-
-
7 September, 2021
Irish HEIs well represented in 2021 Erasmus Mundus Call
-
6 September, 2021
New report confirms positive momentum for EU open science
-
2 September, 2021
European Year of Rail: Connecting Europe Express – All Aboard!
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
28 June, 2021
Pandemic and Research – Survey
-
-
-
-
-
-
14 June, 2021
European Group Statement on ethics and governance
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
19 May, 2021
Co-operation Partnerships Deadline Extended
-
-
-
-
-
-
4 April, 2021
European Innovation Council will have a €10bn Budget
-
25 March, 2021
New Erasmus+ Programme aims to support 10m learners
-
22 March, 2021
Ireland to receive over €27m in Erasmus+ Funding in 2021
-
-
17 March, 2021
Want to know more about the Erasmus+ Programme?
-
12 March, 2021
Carnaval goes virtual at Athlone IT
-
-
-
1 March, 2021
Ireland in 3rd spot in new EU Performance Index
-
-
-
22 February, 2021
EU to invest €150m in Coronavirus Research
-
-
18 February, 2021
UCD, Teagasc and Welsh Universities in Oats Research
-
15 February, 2021
EC Launches New European Bauhaus Initiative
-
3 February, 2021
UCD – Timely Report on Virtual Teaching Approaches
-
2 February, 2021
Almost 4400 HEIs in Europe awarded Erasmus Charter
-
1 February, 2021
Funding Call for Cross-Border Teacher Collaborations Announced
-
21 January, 2021
UCD and TCD to benefit from EU Horizon 2020 funding
-
-
16 December, 2020
Over 5000 events celebrate the Erasmus Programme in 2020
-
12 December, 2020
Next Erasmus+ Programme clears political hurdle
-
6 December, 2020
Erasmus Barometer Survey 2019-2020 Open
-
6 October, 2020
Four Irish HEIs in share of €5m EU Knowledge Alliance Funding
-
-
28 September, 2020
€239,696 in Jean Monnet funding awarded to two Universities
-
27 August, 2020
EU launches COVID Response Project Call
-
20 August, 2020
EC to launch Digital Education Strategic Partnerships Call
-
23 July, 2020
6 Irish HEIs to share in €36m Erasmus Mundus Programme
-
-
-
-
2 July, 2020
Europass: take the next step! New platform launched
-
22 June, 2020
Ulysses Call 2020 – Results
-
-
17 March, 2020
New Deadlines for Erasmus+ Sport Actions
-
12 March, 2020
Coronavirus – Statement from An Taoiseach
-
-
-
27 February, 2020
Erasmus+ Project opens door to Algerian partnership for UL
-
24 February, 2020
Intra-Africa Academic Mobility Scheme fourth Call
-
14 February, 2020
European Policy Experimentations – Call 2020
-
13 February, 2020
Secular cultures more welcoming according to new study
-
-
3 February, 2020
Coronavirus Research Call
-
-
8 January, 2020
Brazilian Universities develop new performance metrics
-
-
20 December, 2019
Photo Competition to celebrate 10 million Erasmus Students
-
16 December, 2019
Erasmus Days 2019 a huge success
-
12 December, 2019
Cork IT Erasmus Student wins prestigious music award
-
11 December, 2019
International Scholarship Call to issue in January 2020
-
8 November, 2019
Erasmus+ 2020 Call and Programme Guide 2020
-
4 November, 2019
Three HEIs in latest Erasmus Mundus awards
-
-
9 September, 2019
The future of European research must be inclusive
-
30 August, 2019
Government Investment to benefit internationalisation
-
28 August, 2019
Almost 100 Mobilities to Palestine in 2018 from Europe
-
26 August, 2019
Latest Edition of the Armenian E+ Office Newsletter
-
12 August, 2019
Irish Universities win nearly €2m of EU support
-
-
-
5 June, 2019
DCU – World Leader in addressing bullying
-
29 May, 2019
Brexit – Continuation of Erasmus+
-
-
-
-
-
11 March, 2019
Old Dominion University on a visit to Ireland
-
10 March, 2019
Carnaval at MIC
-
-
-
27 February, 2019
500 participants attend Palestinian National Erasmus+ Office INFO Day
-
26 February, 2019
Seed funding call for Teacher Education North and South launched
-
22 February, 2019
Universities UK calls on UK government to fund study abroad
-
-
19 February, 2019
U-Multirank Call 2019 – Deadline 1 May 2019
-
7 February, 2019
Erasmus+ and a “No Deal” Brexit – EC Statement
-
1 February, 2019
Erasmus+ Application Deadline extended to 12 February
-
-
20 December, 2018
Unusual Stats for Christmas
-
16 November, 2018
Erasmus+ Languages Survey
-
-
-
24 October, 2018
European Commission publishes Erasmus+ Call 2019
-
8 October, 2018
Mobility under Erasmus+: European Court of Auditors Report
-
17 September, 2018
RCSI to deliver joint pharmacy programme with Chinese University
-
10 September, 2018
World Suicide Prevention Day 10 September 2018
-
-
-
-
28 August, 2018
Finland aims to be at the forefront of the Arctic bioeconomy
-
-
-
14 August, 2018
EU agrees a number of joint initiatives with Japan
-
-
-
-
22 June, 2018
Ireland an EU leader in Innovation
-
21 June, 2018
EU’s External Budget – €123 billion proposed for 2021-27
-
-
-
-
15 June, 2018
Palestine Erasmus+ Office launches newsletter
-
3 June, 2018
Irish SMEs among winners in Commission Programme
-
-
11 May, 2018
RTÉ Brainstorm
-
3 May, 2018
Career Guidance – Public Consultation
-
-
-
27 April, 2018
Global Survey on Internationalisation
-
-
-
17 January, 2023
International Programmes Evaluators – Call 2023
-
13 December, 2022
All About Youth – EU opportunities for young people in Ireland